I make a point to switch off my phone upon entering a cinema. Not simply on do not disturb – completely off. I mention this not to boast, or to suggest that the specter of a classic director will appear to offer approval. I view it as a genuine small luxuries: for a minimum of a couple of hours, I am entirely unreachable. I leave my phone off for the duration of the closing credits as well. It strikes me as indulgent to remain seated as other patrons slowly filter out, lit only by the rolling text.
And, more and more, by the light of the cataloguing app.
More than millions of users engage with Letterboxd, a film-cataloguing application. Like A24, it has evolved into a cultural signifier for a specific type of tastemaker who hypes new releases and revels in revisiting old classics. Users score and write about films, and the most insightful or most articulate critiques ascend to the top, encouraging cinephiles to put in effort.
"If I don't jot down my ideas immediately when the film concludes, my reviews are much less clear and eloquent," said a student.
On a recent visit to the theater, the credits had barely started before the gentleman seated in front of me began typing his assessment. Nearby, a pair sat, looking down, jotting down their respective thoughts.
The late artist David Lynch had a piece of advice: note every spark of inspiration the very second it occurs to you. If you don't, it could vanish, and, as he phrased it: "Losing a good idea, you feel like you could commit suicide." While Lynch spoke to aspiring film-makers, this mindset pertains to the post-film ritual.
A student, a young student in New York, invariably drafts his assessments before leaving the auditorium.
"If I don't jot down my ideas promptly once the movie ends, my reviews are significantly less coherent and articulate," he said. "It requires some time. I'm pretty slow, and my girlfriend isn't fond of it."
Stern attends the movies often – 182 visits the previous year – and is on a first-name basis with the cinema employees, who sometimes need to kick him out so they can start tidying the aisles. He thinks it acceptable to take advantage of the end credits: "When you pay for a movie ticket, the closing sequence are included in the film experience."
The app's most passionate users give credit to the app with reviving excitement around a struggling film industry, where productions are down and work is scarce. (Letterboxd also possesses the kind of user profile advertisers seek – its largest cohort of users is aged 18 and 24, with those aged 25 to 35.)
Excitement begets additional buzz; eagerly anticipated movies see a flurry of activity on Letterboxd shortly following the initial screenings. The highest-rated review of a recent adaptation – "Emily Brontë passed away centuries ago yet this adaptation is still the most egregious event that has ever happened to her" – has received over 50,000 hearts. A separate recent film inspired this comparison to a rival's documentary: "the Eras Tour documentary found dead."
"It feels like an addiction," remarked one user, a 33-year-old New Yorker who is employed in marketing. He also prefers to jot down thoughts throughout the closing scroll. "Processing what you just saw, as soon as you experienced it, aids the cinematic journey. It helps you grasp the key messages of a film. If it evokes a sensation of a warm hug, that's hardly something you retain the next day."
He feels most driven to review a film if it was brilliant – or awful. For example: he recently sat through a star-driven project. "I found myself so disappointed by how egregiously bad it was, that I was keen to whip out my phone and award it a half-star rating," he stated. (This reviewer is a more critical critic than established professional critics, who awarded the film a higher rating, calling it "smart and entertaining fare.")
A social media manager, a twenty-eight-year-old professional who manages social media, saw an acclaimed feature at a neighborhood theater and remained to draft the review ("it received five stars"). He has observed worse behavior: people pulling out their phones to Letterboxd the movie they are in the middle of watching. "That action irritates me," he commented.
One of the movie industry's most enduring urban legends tells of a showing of a pioneering silent short that featured a train entering a station. The medium was in its formative period and – according to this apocryphal anecdote – the shot of a locomotive moving right toward the camera frightened the audience so much that people fled in terror.
Over a century later, movie theater manners remains just as questionable. Often, no one remember how to conduct themselves these days, notably when the lights go down: patrons snap photos of the image, carry in strong-smelling food, and, as occurred during a cultural moment, at times engage in physical altercations.
A number of users have turned to social media to argue over the acceptability of "Letterboxding" in the closing scroll. When one social media user